This page is archived

Fall 2013      MATH:7450 (22M:305) Topics in Topology: Scientific and Engineering Applications of Algebraic Topology

Instructor:  Dr. Isabel K. Darcy
Email: idarcybiomath AT gmail.com

Project:

While other ideas are welcome (for example, creating your own software or teaching material), most projects will focus on analyzing data. We will use a variety of software to perform topological data analysis including MAPPER, JAVAPLEX, PHOM, and DIONYSUS.

PHOM is an R package for calculating persistent homology and can run on Windows, Mac, and Linux. Both PHOM and R are freeware. Instructions on how to install R can be found in the R manual. More elementary instructions (specific to this course) will be made available. The software R is used in both industry and in undergraduate education due to the mathematical power of this freeware. It can also be linked to C, C++, and Fortran code.

While everyone should be able to run the freeware PHOM, the software MAPPER and JAVAPLEX both require access to matlab. Dionysus is a C++ library for computing persistent homology and cohomology. If you are taking this course for credit, you will have access to both matlab and C++.

If you are collaborating with someone, you should decide as a group at the beginning of the semester how the work will be divided and what you would like to accomplish. I will not require that you finish all (or even most parts), but your collaborators can. The following is one potential project outline, but you may follow any journal format you prefer. Note that while the ideal paper would include all of the following, even published papers do not include all (or even most) of the following. You and your collaborators will need to decide what to include. Writing an article that is almost ready for submitting for publication to a good journal (or developing good software or creating sufficient teaching material or etc.) will be sufficient for earning an A in this class.

NOTE: Even published papers do not include all (or even most) of the following. You and your collaborators will need to decide what to include.

1. Abstract.
2. Introduction: Briefly introduce the problem, techniques, and outline the paper. Try to use as few technical terms as possible (or reference section where defined).
3. Background
• Problem description:
Fully describe the problem. Describe how the data is created, what is its format, what are issues that one should consider (for example are their different types of noise), etc. Please keep in mind that people from a variety of backgrounds may be interested in your article, so please help them understand your data. Deeper mathematics can be applied if more people have a better understanding of the problem.
• Mathematical background:
One can reference appropriate papers that describe the methods used in your paper or you can provide the background yourself. Including motivation specific to your problem would be particularly helpful.
4. Results
• Data analysis.
In either the results or discussion section, motivate your choice of software. Software often requires one to choose various values for different parameters. Motivate your parameter choices. Are these choices robust (for example, does one get similar results for different choices of parameter values).
5. Discussion
• What do your results mean?
This will depend on your application. For example, if you find a hole in your data, you might be able to determine exactly where that hole comes from as was done in Adam's and Carlsson's On the nonlinear statistics of range image patches.
• Compare your results to results using other types of data analysis tools.
• Validation:
Part of validation includes motivating and determining the robustness of the choices you made when analyzing the data and comparing your results to previously published results. But another part is to determine if the results give you useful information for your particular problem. For example, a cluster found in Topology based data analysis identifies a subgroup of breast cancers with a unique mutational profile and excellent survival by Nicolau, Levine, and Carlsson was validated by further examining the biological properties of this cluster. Of course, this requires laboratory experiments which your collaborators may or may not be able to perform.
6. Conclusion
7. Acknowledgement
You should acknowledge anyone who has provided significant feedback. If you publish the results of your project, please acknowledge this course. If I provide you with significant helpful feedback, you are also welcome to acknowledge me.
8. Author contribution
Summarize who contributed what to the paper (who designed, computed, analyzed, wrote, etc.).
9. Funding sources and conflicts of interest
10. References
This is a very important part of your paper. It lets the reader know where to find additional information. One is also required to reference other people's ideas, analysis, conclusions, figures, etc (even if modified, reworded, or redrawn). Using other people's work without acknowledgment constitutes plagerism. For figures, one may also need to obtain copyright permission if you submit your paper for publication, and redrawing a figure may be discouraged.

If you prefer to write software, there are many potential projects. One example (as suggested by Rama Kunapuli) would be to write a Sage interface to call the R subroutines in PHOM as well as the C++ subroutines in Dionysus.